Prime Minister Rudd's personal interest in Asia and his two recent trips to the region have highlighted the importance to Australia of understanding why people think and act the way they do there. In Japan in mid-June, Mr. Rudd mentioned that he'd like to see Australia become, over time, the most Asia-literate country in the world.
That's an admirable aim, especially after the damaging slippage in Asian studies over the past decade. But we have a lot of work to do even to point in the right direction, let alone come anywhere near to achieving such a reasonable goal.
A key shaper of public opinion on these matters is the media. If reporters and commentators don't bother to get the names of the region's top people and places correct, opting instead for their own imagined pronunciation, then Australians will be left feeling that it's not a challenge worth taking seriously.
Only weeks out from the Beijing Olympics, China's capital is still commonly mispronounced (think of Jing as in Jingle Bells and you'll be safe). True, there are many outstanding performers, such as the ABC's Beijing correspondent, who takes great care. But equally there are others who feel no obligation to get it right, like his counterpart in Tokyo, who's lived there for a few years. He managed up to three mistakes in most of his reports on the PM's recent Japan trip: the name of the Japanese Prime Minster, that of the Emperor, and then Hiroshima. He inserted an emphatic ROSH into that name, something that might cause the Japanese to laugh to themselves but for the human tragedy that occurred there.
Hiroshima is written with two Chinese characters. Hiro means wide or spread out, while shima means islands: in effect, a flat, basin estuary.
The most universal mistake in Australia's Asian lexicon would have to be Taiwan, which is regularly pronounced as Taiwon. Won, of course, is the currency unit of South Korea. Think of One - as in 1,2,3 - and you'll get it right.
All of this may sound petty to the average Australian, but in Asia it rarely passes unnoticed. It is seen as reflective of a widespread attitudinal problem on our part: we simply don't care because we believe we'll be able to define a reality of our own choice in the region.
A good place for Kevin Rudd to start might be with his own government, ensuring that none of his ministers offends on this front. Most commonly do. He might then work his way round the senior ranks of the bureaucracy.
Australians who are attracted to Asian studies will inevitably have to toil away at one or more of the region's languages. And the one thing that will hamstring them - before they even start - will be the abysmal grounding in English grammar that they're endowed with by Australia's school system. Let's face it, you ever only realise how fundamental your home grammar is when you study another language, especially one from a vastly different cultural or civilization bailiwick. Put simply, you're floundering without it.
For most of us, that's the beginning of the Asian studies process. Few of us are lucky enough to be born to parents posted in the region.
But what of the end? Do we simply arrive at a point of Buddhist nirvana where full fluencies flourish and Asian mind-reading becomes a piece of cake?
It's hardly as straightforward as that. There's no one destination, unless of course, you have a specific aim like becoming a simultaneous interpreter. In that case, perfection is pretty much your goal. For the majority though, you don't necessarily know when you've arrived. You just keep going.
This was brought home to me recently in a conversation with an Australian woman who's had a lot to do with Japan. She's been married to two Japanese and is bringing up children from both relationships. She lives in Tokyo and has a sophisticated knowledge of both the language and the customs that go with it.
A short time ago, at a mother's meeting there, she said she sat back and listened, appreciating at long last that while she was fully acquainted with all the subtleties of the language and the people, she was simply never going to become a full Japanese. It had nothing to do with not being accepted. Her local community had taken her in with open arms.
"I suddenly realised," she told me, "that there's actually no end point. I'd just kept going all these years, assuming that at some stage a bell would ring and I'd know that I was over the finishing line and into a land of cultural bliss."
Back at the start of the game we need to discuss with young Australians what it is that they expect to achieve, how to watch out for key sign posts along the way and how to enjoy progress as it's made rather than miss it because they're busy scanning the horizon for a magical pot of gold.
Warren Reed was a postgraduate scholarship student in the Law Faculty of Tokyo University 35 years ago, where a fluency in written and spoken Japanese was essential. He has since been involved in intelligence work, business, writing and media commentary, and along the way has also studied Chinese, Indonesian and Arabic.
Comments
The value of the journey
A greater emphasis on Asian Languages in the curruculum is marvellous idea on a number of levels. Not only would it provide us with a firmer cultural and linguistic base to engage in our geographical region, but it would also provide us with the opportunity to make greater use of the tremendous cultural wealth we already have available in our own country.
I know countless Mandarin speakers in Sydney, many of whom would be well placed to become teachers if only they were given the opportunity. Most are working in trades well below their competence because we show far less patience at the mispronounciation of our our tongue, than we expect from our neighbours.
I am currently reading a book called On the Smell of an Oily Rag: speaking English, thinking Chinese and living Australian Ouyang Yu, and I would commend it to anyone who is interested in the similarities and differences between mainland Chinese and Australian culture and language.
I think integrating more language and cultural studies into the syllabus at a primary, secondary and tertiary level would enable us to take advantage of this wonderful resource, and I believe create a more cohesive community.
However I don't think that fluency should be the only goal of learning a language. I often hear people comment that they tried to learn a language but failed, which of course means they didn't reach a level of fluency which they had initially sought. What they don't realise is, as you so rightly point out, you never fully learn a language, not even your mother toungue. Nonetheless, any amount of time dedicated towards studing another language and the associated culture is better than none - if for no other reason than it teaches you that there are thing you don't know. Even a nodding understanding of an Asian language or culture would be enough to prevent many of the missunderstandings and prejudices which detract from our ability to engage with Asia, and the rest of the non-english speaking world.
I was interested to see in the outcomes of the 2020 Forum the suggestion that we conduct more student exchange programs within our region, and I think this is also a marvellous suggestion, as it's a great way not only to get our kids linguistically and culturally up to speed with other countries, but it also will provide them with some insight into our own culture through the eyes of others.
Can I Enjoy a Guilt-free Olympics?
I agree... there's an undeniable economic and cultural shift towards East Asia, and particularly China. Australians have to tear themselves away from the Anglo-European centric cultural position we've held since this young country's birth. Do we really need French in school? Don't quote me on this, but I've a hunch that learning Mandarin might get you further in your professional career.
But to change tack slightly... or quite significantly.
These days, every time I check out the BBC or SBS news there's another unhappy report being filed from China. With only weeks to go before the start of the Beijing Olympics they're still jamming the TV screens and airwaves. Images of earthquakes or Tibetan protestors or conflict in the predominantly Muslim Northwest are affecting my breathing like the smog-filled streets of Beijing, and tainting my otherwise boundless enthusiasm for the mighty Olympic Games.
You know what I really want to do?
I want to settle back on to my comfy sofa and take in the world's greatest show. I want to devour scores of jumbo sized bags of super nacho flavoured cornchips while watching the Mongolians take on Burkina Faso in the women's handball.
I want to see the grace, athleticism, victory, defeat, euphoria and heartbreak, like a modern day Shakespeare play in Speedos.
And I want to do this all without feeling guilty about enjoying these games as political, environmental and social problems beset the country.
And I think I can... Despite all these tragedies, China is quickly challenging the US as the world's leading economic power, and tens of millions are being lifted out of poverty. Wen Bo of the NGO Pacific Environment, a group that monitors environmental issues in the Pacific Rim, explains that China has invested billions of dollars into environmental initiatives, promising that the 2008 Olympics will be the greenest ever. Although China still faces countless acute ecological problems, it's undeniable that these Games have invigorated the nation's environmental movement.
The number of "Blue sky" days are increasing, say reporters in Beijing. I'm breathing a little easier...
True, during the Olympics, residents of Beijing will temporarily lose many of their new freedoms, so the Chinese government can project an image of a perfectly oiled machine to the rest of the world. Curbing the questionable habit of spitting in public places, I can understand. But stopping residents from wearing white socks with black shoes, although a clear fashion faux pas, is I think a tad extreme.
But fashion gaffes aside.
We mustn't forget that about one-sixth of the world's population live in China, a nation full of both ethnic and geological rifts. Like anywhere else, there's bound to be seismic activity - both culturally and environmentally. I'm not justifying the government's policies or trivialising the incomprehensible tragedy of the natural disasters in China. I do, however, understand that it's a story that's been repeated throughout history.
Although we must remain vigilant, and put pressure on China to improve its human rights' record, we can also allow them their time in the sun. And, as most people recognise, the sun is just rising over China.
As an Olympic host, China has finally been acknowledged as a major player in the global village. Personally I think this might be the best way to really open up the nation, so they can engage more freely in an international dialogue.
So, I've piled up the fluffy cushions, and allocated a spot for my cat in front of the TV. The beer is in the fridge and the nacho cornchips are waiting.
I'm going to try my best to enjoy a guilt-free Olympics.